1.5M parents use this app. 70% of the reviews are bad.
Posted on
| Platform | Views |
|---|---|
| YouTube (opens in a new tab)Checked | 0 |
About this video
Before building an app, I want proof that people already use something like it and are unhappy with it. App reviews show both. In this video I walk through Gaps on Trend Seeker. It collects reviews from Google Play, the App Store, Product Hunt and TrustMRR, turns them into embeddings and groups them into clusters. Those clusters become business ideas and categories worth competing in. Then I go through real examples: a baby tracker where 69.9% of reviews are bad after it became a paid product, a cash-reward game where players can't get their money out, the Health & Fitness category, small apps with almost only negative reviews, recent Product Hunt launches, niches like AI character chat, and companies with known monthly revenue. I've made the mistake of building for a problem nobody would pay for more than once. This is how I check first. Chapters 0:00 70% bad reviews, 1.5M parents 0:24 Which app ideas have real demand? 2:10 Not every bad review is an opportunity 4:30 How Gaps works 5:19 This week's gaps 8:43 Categories: where users are least happy 10:22 Small apps with very unhappy users 12:16 Recent launches 14:47 Niches and monthly revenue 17:04 Don't build into a void Gaps: https://trend-seeker.app/gaps Questions or feature ideas for Gaps? Tell me in the comments. #IndieHacker #MarketResearch #BuildInPublic #AppIdeas
Transcript
that 70% of the reviews are bad reviews for this Nara Baby and Pregnancy Tracker. But this app has 1.5 million parents served. So here there is a clear problem. Hello everyone, I've been building Trend Seeker and trying to find new business ideas and to detect signals from the internet about what businesses to build and what people are having problem with and what are they asking solutions in the internet so I could find a business idea to create out of it and start an online business. As you can see maybe people are are saying that they have problems with the nine month old no longer taking bottle. So parent problems are usually big part of the questions people are having but this doesn't mean that this is an a profitable business idea because parents normally also get help from their friends and this industry is relatively saturated and you could say a legacy industry they could also look at the job ads and Google trends for example but the other way is to look at the app reviews and this is a very specific way to go because here you have also a clear demand because if you have an app and you have people reviewing it negatively and already putting feedback in the app review then you can understand that there is an opportunity there that the app is not as useful as the people would like and then you could make your own application and make a better one and capture the market share from the original players. Okay, now let's look at some of these app reviews here. I will select app reviews only, so we don't get any Reddit threads here, all podcast signals, all job ads, but only app reviews now. But now you can look at which app the reviewer is reviewing And here you can see Apple Music, which is a very big app and a very big industry that is hard for an indie hat to come in alone and start disrupting by himself only. But for music players and music streaming platforms like Apple Music and Spotify, then probably you're out of your league if you want to start creating a competitor to those. But as you can see, now we got to this point where we understood that some apps and some industries are better for our solo entrepreneur or a small company to come into than others. And so how would we understand which specific apps are worthwhile to compete with and also the categories of apps and specific niches. So what you would need probably is to understand how many app reviews there are for this category or application. If there are millions of reviews, then probably there is also a lot of competition. But if this is a smaller application or a new category of applications, like for instance right now AI applications or UGC video applications, then you could potentially disrupt it earlier or more easily. And for this I created the trend-seeker.app/gaps where I give an overview about these properties and then you can consider yourself on the specific apps and categories that you can potentially compete with. Okay, so how does Gaps work? So Gaps look at the app and product across Google Play, Apple App Store, Product Hunt, just MRR. And here you can see that for Google Play we have 36,000 signals, for Apple App Store 14,000 and more for Product Hunt and other platforms. reviews and then create embeddings out of them and then match them into clusters. And these clusters can be used to create business ideas or to find categories that have the potential to of being a competition target. Okay let's take a look at Gaps website and what do we have available here then. We have a newsletter that every week combines all of our data, our app reviews and then you can subscribe to it and it will send you two of the best gaps for the week we think are worthwhile to look at. So this one was baby tracking. As I told you before, people are having always problems with these kind of apps. And as you can see, that 70% of the reviews are bad reviews for this Nara baby and pregnancy tracker. But this app has 1.5 million parents served. So here there is a clear problem. If 70% find something negative, then you have the opportunity here to make a better application. It could be the cost or the complexity of how to use the app or something else. But 70% of bad reviews is a clear sign to take a look at this specific app. Okay, we can see about the look at the negative reviews and then I was right about this, that the reviews are about it now becoming a paid product. And you can see there's a stream of reviews that people have been using and it's a great application. But now that I logged in, I'm seeing that I have to pay for it. And these reviews are from only a few weeks ago. So you can clearly see that users are unhappy right now and they're looking for another solution. like this one, like now you have to pay for a subscription. People don't like the subscription. So here you have the opportunity to maybe potentially create a free app with maybe some ads. So you could monetize in other ways. Maybe you could do some co-ops with other companies and then put their products into the application. If your app gets popular, then you could create a YouTube channel and start creating maybe tutorials or other baby-related videos and start asking money for this. So there's an opportunity here to make this application free but monetize it in other ways. But clearly a lot of people are unhappy here about the recent payment changes. And let's see about the other one. Misplay, play games, earn cash. this sounds like a kind of a scam application when iPhone reviewers say that you cannot take money out of the app yeah so I'm reading the reviews here and the reviews are about that the payments are very low that one guy plays it for a few months and gets only 15 dollars back and the other one is reviewing that it takes a long time to get the money out that you apply to take it out it takes four to five days to receive it. So clearly people are not happy with this application as well and there is an opportunity to create a better app. Okay let's continue then you can explore app and product categories here so if you're interested in creating artificial intelligence apps, developer tools apps, business apps, education apps, Then you can just click on it and you can see what kind of apps have bad reviews. So for example, we could check the health and fitness category. And here you can see that a lot of apps have bad reviews. Like even here the MyFitnessPal has 46% of bad reviews. Weight Watchers program has only 10% of bad reviews. so this seems like a very legitimate app if only have 3% of the weight-loss users that had a bad experience with this application but if you're looking again this Flo cycle and period tracker and Calm as well has 21% of bad reviews so there are a lot of opportunities there and for the hiking application 20% of bad reviews but for this one, Pacer and Pedometer StepCounter you would probably not want to make a competing product because it only got 1.1% of bad reviews but a very popular app so if you ever started noticing bad reviews here then you could come in immediately and start offering an alternative. Now for the next section we have start with the signal and here we will find smaller audience applications that have a lot of bad reviews. So if you look at this app it has 173 reviews are negative. So this is worthwhile to take a look at because obviously people are not happy. I'm not familiar with this application. I know there are a lot of matchmaking applications out there. So potentially this app also introduced some kind of an hidden fee that people found negative. but you could explore more products here that have a small market and bad reviews because these are I think specifically good for indie hackers because if you have less users then probably the product is also easier to make and because there isn't such a big market then the bigger companies are not competing with you and you have more potential as a single person to break through. You can see that there's a Procreate pocket that you can use to create sketches, rich paintings, but 63% of the people are saying that it's a bad application. So this is a good way to explore the applications that have a small market and a big unhappy crowd that is looking for a better solution for their problems. In the next section we have a recent launcher. So this is a good way to keep your hand on the pulse on what people have released lately. So if you look at the Fundraisly or Goldfish or Upstream they have over a thousand upvotes in their platforms which means people are interested in these applications and because they are releasing them these are also new markets and here when the market is new and developing it's also a good opportunity to come in and offer well first review their product see what it does and give your own unique perspective on how you would improve it and launch a competitor. So we can say, they can look at the Goldfish for example. So this is a memory application which records your progress on your Mac and then allows you to write more human sounding replies and posts because as you know, the AI writes in a very specific way and that is recognizable for other people but this application then records how you write and then suggests and writes like you would. So I think this is a great application and I'm working on a similar product myself, so I wouldn't pay for it, but maybe if I'm creating my product and I have been creating it already, then I could offer an alternative for the Goldfish. Okay, here we have another section for smaller apps with traction, so these are a little bit bigger now compared to our previous section where we have less than 10 million installs and 100.000 store ratings so a bit bigger applications but for example for this very simple one that plans your workouts but they still have a lot of bad ratings here like this This is a fake app, not good. And I was thinking it was free, but then I was just a yearly subscription. I cannot cancel the application. So this is another application to take a look at, to potentially great than a competitor to. Now, as the last section, this is a quite a nice section where we actually gather the together so we combine multiple similar applications as you can see we have emoji mingo talk and flipped and f easy but you can say they are all ai character chat so this means that people are are chatting with their ai characters inside their application but as you can see over 30% of the reviews for these applications are negative. So this is a new and developing category of applications with the recent AI developments and you can see that there are a lot of people that are having problems with them and also this means it's a very good category to try to compete in. and the same one for short video creation applications and AI roleplay studios and you can explore more niches here in the niches path. And as the last link we have the market research and here you could specifically find the companies and the specific monthly recurring revenue and try to compete with this company specifically. So if you can see that the company has 10,000 per month revenue and you could look at their application and category and see if you can compete with them, then you already have proof of the market validation and that people are willing to pay for it. And this is also a very good opportunity to find a proven market you can then filter by the MRR size here. Go for the bigger markets if you are more experienced and smaller markets if you want to try something out and compete with more easier apps. okay so this was what I wanted to talk to you about this day on about how to do market research before creating your application to ensure that you are not building into a void where there is no market and no one would pay for application and instead you can verify that to pay for it. People are already downloading and using these applications and are having problems with them. And then you can come in and make a better product and sell to this same market and start earning money. I have made this mistake myself multiple times that I start making applications that I think are useless to me or useful for me. But in the end, I am working on such a specific problem that there are no users for it and no one is willing to pay for them. always do your market research before starting to build your own product. Okay and if you have any questions about the Gaps website or if you want any new features then let me know in the comments below. Don't forget to like and subscribe and see you in the next video.